TJES Review Form

Welcome in Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences TJES Review Form

Before start, you may want to read Reviewer Guidelines

 

Step 1

Reviewer information

Review Form

Review Form

Step 3

Reviewer Comments and Recommendation

  • Reviewer information
  • Review Form
  • Comments and Recommendation

Reviewer information

Title

Reviewer Full name

Affiliations

E-mail

Alternative E-mail

Phon Number with Country Code

Research interests

Article Information

Article Title

Article Code

Review Form

Please select a number to indicate your level of agreement with the following questions. Select the lowest value (1) to indicate that you disagree entirely, or the highest value (5) to indicate that you agree completely.

The paper is within the scope of TJES journal

The paper title reflects the content and purpose of the research.

Your comments about article title

The abstract includes information important for understanding the content of the paper.

Your comments about abstract

The introduction clearly defines the purpose and objective of the work

Your comments about the introduction

A review of previous researches are good and up to date

Your comments about review of previous researches

The methodology is clearly and adequate

your comments about methodology

The results and discussions are adequate

your comments about results and discussions

The conclusions is based and contributes to the discharge of treated problems

Your comments about conclusions

The references reflect the topicality of the article, and up to date

your comments about references

The paper is free of technical errors

The paper is clearly readable

Your comments about 1-The paper is clearly readable and 2-The paper is free of technical errors

The figures are clear & do clearly convey the intended message.

Please evaluate the number of figures that accompany this manuscript

The Tables are clear & do clearly convey the intended message.

Your comment about figures and tables

The length of the paper is appropriate.

the subject addressed in this article is worthy of investigation.

please rate the novelty of the information (with 1 • previously published and 5 • completely new)

Please rate the quality of the language and writing style (with 1 - unacceptable and 5 - ready to publish as is)

Did this paper make sense?

Reviewer comments and Recommendation

Comments to the Authors

Comments to TJES Editor

Comments and/or suggestions to TJES Journal about Review Form

Reviewer Recommendation

Please select one

Return manuscript after reply from Author If you have corrections

Supplementary file (optional) (Please upload any file such as annotated manuscripts, image and/or related materials)

File 1 (To ensure that the file has been uploaded the file name will be switched form choose a file to the name of the attachment file)للتاكد من ان الملف قد تم تحميله سيتم استبدال كلمة(اختيار ملف ) الى اسم الملف المرفق

File 1 (To ensure that the file has been uploaded the file name will be switched form choose a file to the name of the attachment file)للتاكد من ان الملف قد تم تحميله سيتم استبدال كلمة(اختيار ملف ) الى اسم الملف المرفق